Sydney 5th April 2023 – Embargoed until 00:01 AM AEST on […]
Investor property mortgages undergo high levels of scrutiny from the media, politicians and the regulators. While Australia is well served by a large number of lenders competing for a share of the $500+ billion market, according to new Consumer Atlas research by DBM Consultants, its results show that customers vary widely in their rating of their investment property home loana nd it would be worthwhile shopping around.
DBM’s Research Director, Dhruba Gupta, said the variations came down, in part, to customer service. “While the Big 4 banks would be expected to have similar products and pricing policies across the nation, they clearly appear to vary in how their products are delivered in the different markets.”
Property investors borrowing from one of the Big 4 rated their satisfaction with their investment mortgage (average of 7.1 out of 10) similar to non-Big 4 banks (average of 7.2 out of 10). While there was not much difference among the Big 4 overall (who between them account for about 80% of the market), there was a wide variation in the ratings among the non-Big 4 banks and non-bank lenders.
Mr Gupta said interestingly, when we looked at the ratings in detail, we saw that the ratings were quite diverse across states.
“In the eastern states, for example, a non-major lender rated highest whilst in SA and WA, a Big 4 occupied top spot. Online bank ING (8.2) was rated the best in NSW, whilst Bendigo Bank (8.1) rated highest in Victoria. Heritage Bank scored best in Queensland (8.2). In SA, both Westpac and ANZ shared first position while in WA, CBA was the stand out leader across all mortgage providers.”
“With the restrictions imposed by APRA on investor borrowing with the Big 4, they need to be more vigilant in protecting their share of the eastern states market. They have the most to lose,” he said.
Among the Big 4 there were inconsistencies in the investor property customer ratings across operating regions. Westpac attracted the most polarised views across the nation, with its SA customers being the most satisfied (7.5), well ahead of its least satisfied customers in Victoria (6.4). Customers of CBA were more consistently rated where Victorian customers gave the highest ratings (7.5) and NSW customers the lowest (7.0).
Lender ratings were also found to be rated differently depending on whether customers lived in metro and non-metropolitan areas. Customers in non-metropolitan areas rated Bendigo Bank (+1.0), Bank of Queensland (+0.8), NAB (+0.7) and Westpac (+0.5) significantly higher than investor property borrowers living in metropolitan areas. On the other hand, CBA was rated significantly higher in metro areas (+0.6). Mr Gupta said that “the differences reflected, in part, to the different strengths of the sales and service activities among the competitors”.
Customer ratings also varied over time across providers. Some improved their ratings while others declined. Investment mortgages from Bank SA (+1.5), ME Bank (+1.2) and ING (+0.5) were rated higher while St. George (-0.5), Bankwest (-0.6) and Suncorp (-1.5) ratings declined over time. The Big 4 banks were relatively more consistently rated than the smaller banks and non-bank lenders. Only NAB registered significantly improved ratings over time.
“These results suggest that some institutions provide a better experience during sign-up but over time do not follow-up with the same level of service over the life of the loan. They could be vulnerable to defection when the customer is in the market for their next loan product. Others improve their servicing over time as they become more familiar with the customer and are more likely to retain the valuable mortgage business,” said Mr Gupta.
“Overall, the results from customer ratings are telling us that the providers of mortgages for investment properties vary widely in what they offer and there is no one that is consistently top rated across all the markets they serve. It should therefore pay to shop around especially among the lenders that are well regarded in each market.”
Sydney 5th April 2023 – Embargoed until 00:01 AM AEST on […]
A recent study of DBM Connect panelists reveals SME attitudes towards emissions, how their business is responding to the emissions challenge, and their expectations of suppliers and business partners.
By Tony Williams, Executive Director, DBM Consultants & Lucas Carreras, […]
DBM Managing Director Dhruba Gupta shares 2 fundamental things financial services marketers should know to boost marketing ROI.
With more people working from home since lockdown, expectations and attitudes relating to bill increases in utilities, telco and insurance have changed.
DBM Connect 2021 IWD Poll February-March 2021, sample size 1046.
When to DIY (your Market research survey) or not
While super funds will next year be held to a […]
Unlocks deeper consumer profiling, specifically for the financial services sector […]
DBM tracks financial services usage and behaviour monthly (for both […]
Dhruba Gupta, Founder and Managing Director of DBM presented the […]
The latest DBM Atlas data has revealed that renters are […]
While the implications of COVID-19 have only become apparent to […]
In a first for the Australian market, a survey of […]
5th March 2020 The 2020 DBM Australian Financial Awards were presented in […]
Eyeota, the leading audience technology platform enabling the intelligent use […]
DBM has today appointed Kipling Zubevich as CEO, tasked with […]
It’s 2020, and we’re celebrating with a brand new logo. […]
DBM are thrilled to announce being honoured at the Campaign […]
There's a new kid on the block targeting millennials living […]
For all the media coverage, chatter and Twitter emojis, do […]
The Winter 2019 DBM In Full Focus report – an […]
The financial confidence of both the general public and businesses […]
The latest DBM In Full Focus report - an insight […]
It’s no secret that 2018 was a tumultuous year for […]
The 2019 DBM Australian Financial Awards were presented in Sydney […]
Findings from ME Bank's 15th bi-annual Household Financial Comfort report (HFCR), […]
Trust in Australia’s big banks is at an all-time low […]
I can easily cite the statistics on women in the […]
New findings show an estimated 220,000 Australians intend to switch […]
Increasing numbers of superannuation customers are expressing their dissatisfaction with […]
AMP’s Net Promoter Score (NPS*) has plummeted 10 points since […]
According to the latest Consumer Atlas results, financial institutions separate […]
Research by DBM Consultants using Consumer ATLAS data reveals that […]
New results from DBM Consultants show that market share and […]
New findings from DBM Consultants’ Consumer Atlas reveal that fewer […]
Latest survey confirms damage done to Big 4 banks in […]
With the owner occupier mortgage market worth about $1 trillion, […]
You might find this hard to believe, but a sizeable […]
Investor property mortgages undergo high levels of scrutiny from the […]